Opinion Magazine
Number of visits: 9464261
  •  Home
  • Opinion
    • Opinion
    • Literature
    • Short Stories
    • Photo Stories
    • Cartoon
    • Interview
    • User Feedback
  • English Bazaar Patrika
    • Features
    • OPED
    • Sketches
  • Diaspora
    • Culture
    • Language
    • Literature
    • History
    • Features
    • Reviews
  • Gandhiana
  • Poetry
  • Profile
  • Samantar
    • Samantar Gujarat
    • History
  • Ami Ek Jajabar
    • Mukaam London
  • Sankaliyu
    • Digital Opinion
    • Digital Nireekshak
    • Digital Milap
    • Digital Vishwamanav
    • એક દીવાદાંડી
    • काव्यानंद
  • About us
    • Launch
    • Opinion Online Team
    • Contact Us

Jinnah and Gujarat ni Asmita (Pride of Gujarat)

Urvish Kothari|English Bazaar Patrika - Features|1 December 2012

Mahamed Ali Jinnah, founding father of Pakistan and responsible,although not solely for the partition of the undivided India, has engineered posthumously yet another break-up.

This time he's pushed the Bharatiya Janata Party into a partition mode. Jaswant Singh, a veteran BJP leader & one of the recent converts to the rebels camp,- the only one to be pampered with prestigious chairmanship of Parliament's Public Accoung Commitee (PAC) even after his rebellion, has added fuel to the dying ambers of Jinnah controversy that nearly burnt L K Advani's political career.

This time Jaswant has revisited partition history and Jinnah's 'innocent' role in it in his latest book. Not without disastarous consequences,though.

For a national party like the BJP what caught everyone by surprise was the incredible speed with which it stepped. This is especially more remarkable after a killing Lok Sabha polls.The party telephonically booted out Jaswant.

As he got bounced from the the party, Jaswant ruefully pondered over what he got as a reward for after serving it for more than 3 decades. His appreciation of Jinnah servedas the proverbial last straw), there was more in store for the Rajasthan leader. His book has been banned by the Gujarat Chief Minister Nanrendra Modi who thinks of himself as the self-appointed custodian of the image of Sardar Patel. The State Government claimed Singh's book tarnishes the image of the original Sardar of India. How could Modi and Advani half-mockingly hailed by many as the chhote sardars" tolerate a publication finding fault with the Iron Man of India.

Well, politics apart, Jinnah's Gujarat connection is quite known. His father Zinabhai/ઝીણાભાઈ (from whose name Mahmad Ali drew his last name 'Jinnah') belonged to Paneli in Kathiawad, few kms. away from birth place of Gandhi. Though born in Karachi, Mahmad Ali was well versed with his Pitrubhasha/ Fathertongue. Here is the sample of how good he was even at written Gujarati.

The page below (from iconic Gujaraty Monthly 'Visami Sadi', May, 1916) depicts answers of some simple questions in Mahmad Ali's own handwritings. Yes, he signed as માહમદ અલી ઝીણા / Maahmad Ali Zina in Gujarati. The column is titled 'Dil no ekrar' (hearty confession).

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The page roughly translates as:

Admirable virtue of a Man : Independence

Admirable Virtue of a Woman : Loyality

Success in life, according to you : Securing love from people

Favourite recreation : Horse-riding

Favourite flower : Lily

Favourite writer: Shakespear

Favourite book: Monte cresto

Motto: Never get disppointed

The page can be found at http://www.gujarativisamisadi.com

(On home page Index, click Shirshak and in the long list of titles, click on the first Dil No Ekrar)

Loading

1 December 2012 admin
← રાજ્યમાં મહિલા નીતિની વ્યાપક ચર્ચા જરૂરી
Modi’s McLuhan moment →

Search by

Opinion

  • ઝુબિન ગર્ગ અને ડૉ. હિમા સાને : જીવનની મર્યાદા મનની મર્યાદા નથી
  • GSTમાં રાહત આભાસી છે …?
  • સત્યનો અવાજ દબાવવો એટલે લોકશાહીની હત્યા !
  • વાંચનનો વ્યાયામ : પુસ્તકો વાંચતા લોકો બે વર્ષ લાંબુ જીવે છે!
  • લદ્દાખની લડતઃ શાસન સામે સ્વાયત્તતા, ગૌરવ અને રાજકારણનો જંગ

Diaspora

  • ઉત્તમ શાળાઓ જ દેશને મહાન બનાવી શકે !
  • ૧લી મે કામદાર દિન નિમિત્તે બ્રિટનની મજૂર ચળવળનું એક અવિસ્મરણીય નામ – જયા દેસાઈ
  • પ્રવાસમાં શું અનુભવ્યું?
  • એક બાળકની સંવેદના કેવું પરિણામ લાવે છે તેનું આ ઉદાહરણ છે !
  • ઓમાહા શહેર અનોખું છે અને તેના લોકો પણ !

Gandhiana

  • શું ડો. આંબેડકરે ફાંસીની સજા જનમટીપમાં ફેરવી દેવાનું કહ્યું હતું? 
  • અમારાં કાલિન્દીતાઈ
  • સ્વરાજ પછી ગાંધીજીએ ઉપવાસ કેમ કરવા પડ્યા?
  • કચ્છમાં ગાંધીનું પુનરાગમન !
  • સ્વતંત્ર ભારતના સેનાની કોકિલાબહેન વ્યાસ

Poetry

  • શૂન્ય …
  • મહેંક
  • બણગાં ફૂંકો ..
  • ગણપતિ બોલે છે …
  • એણે લખ્યું અને મેં બોલ્યું

Samantar Gujarat

  • ખાખરેચી સત્યાગ્રહ : 1-8
  • મુસ્લિમો કે આદિવાસીઓના અલગ ચોકા બંધ કરો : સૌને માટે એક જ UCC જરૂરી
  • ભદ્રકાળી માતા કી જય!
  • ગુજરાતી અને ગુજરાતીઓ … 
  • છીછરાપણાનો આપણને રાજરોગ વળગ્યો છે … 

English Bazaar Patrika

  • Letters by Manubhai Pancholi (‘Darshak’)
  • Vimala Thakar : My memories of her grace and glory
  • Economic Condition of Religious Minorities: Quota or Affirmative Action
  • To whom does this land belong?
  • Attempts to Undermine Gandhi’s Contribution to Freedom Movement: Musings on Gandhi’s Martyrdom Day

Profile

  • અમારાં કાલિન્દીતાઈ
  • સ્વતંત્ર ભારતના સેનાની કોકિલાબહેન વ્યાસ
  • જયંત વિષ્ણુ નારળીકરઃ­ એક શ્રદ્ધાંજલિ
  • સાહિત્ય અને સંગીતનો ‘સ’ ઘૂંટાવનાર ગુરુ: પિનુભાઈ 
  • સમાજસેવા માટે સમર્પિત : કૃષ્ણવદન જોષી

Archives

“Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery that mediocrity can pay to greatness.” – Oscar Wilde

Opinion Team would be indeed flattered and happy to know that you intend to use our content including images, audio and video assets.

Please feel free to use them, but kindly give credit to the Opinion Site or the original author as mentioned on the site.

  • Disclaimer
  • Contact Us
Copyright © Opinion Magazine. All Rights Reserved