Opinion Magazine
Number of visits: 9448625
  •  Home
  • Opinion
    • Opinion
    • Literature
    • Short Stories
    • Photo Stories
    • Cartoon
    • Interview
    • User Feedback
  • English Bazaar Patrika
    • Features
    • OPED
    • Sketches
  • Diaspora
    • Culture
    • Language
    • Literature
    • History
    • Features
    • Reviews
  • Gandhiana
  • Poetry
  • Profile
  • Samantar
    • Samantar Gujarat
    • History
  • Ami Ek Jajabar
    • Mukaam London
  • Sankaliyu
    • Digital Opinion
    • Digital Nireekshak
    • Digital Milap
    • Digital Vishwamanav
    • એક દીવાદાંડી
    • काव्यानंद
  • About us
    • Launch
    • Opinion Online Team
    • Contact Us

Lessons lost

Ghaleb Cachalia|English Bazaar Patrika - Features|1 December 2014

Gandhi famously called for the Indian National Congress to be dissolved. It had done its job by ending British rule. The wise and wizened Mahatma called for a new organization to serve the people of India; one that would eschew corruption.

According to Venkat Ram Kalyanam – the only living witness to the assassination of Gandhi five months after independence – Gandhi received more than fifty letters daily from freedom fighters and concerned citizens. Most of the letters were about the rampant corruption and cronyism of Congress ministers. Gandhi shared his views with Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru – to no avail.

Kalyanam says Gandhi dictated a note – his last major missive – penned towards the end of 1947, in which he said “I am not responsible for what is happening in this country. I have repeatedly said that I have neither any part nor any say in many things that are going on in the country today. The plain matter of fact is that I am no longer the current coin I fancied I once was. My voics in the wilderness. My writ runs no more. Time was when whatever I said the masses followed. Today, mine is a lone voice. I now say things which do not go home. I know that I am a back number. Yet, I go on saying what I believe to be true.”

Prophetic stuff, this, and so very relevant to the ANC and South Africa twenty years since the fall of Apartheid – Marikana, Nkandla and the recent shenanigans in parliament are but recent pointers towards a decline that began some time ago.

Mandela, like Nehru, formed the first government and the real rot began towards the end of Mandela’s term and the start of Thabo Mbeki’s. It started with the arms deal, the proceeds of which provided the ANC with much needed cash and many intermediaries with fat personal rewards. No one really needs a commission of inquiry to obfuscate or elucidate – it’s a fact – sad and indisputably responsible for our moral decay.

The precedent was set and since certain local and international businesses and the ANC government have conspired to deliver on the creation of wealth for some and proportionally little for the masses who repeatedly vote – depressingly – for a party that has delivered little, fueled by a mixture of hope and ignorance.

Growth is forecast to be lower than 2%. Inflation is 5.7%. Compared to the other BRICS countries, the South African national government’s gross-loan-debt-to-GDP ratio exceeds that of Russia and China.

Unemployment hovers around 25% – the highest among BRICS countries. Homicide rates per 100 000 sit at 27.3 – trumped only by Guatemala, El Salvador, Cote d’Ivoire and Brazil. The police force is largely corrupt and in disarray. We spend more on health as a percentage of GDP than other BRICS countries and still the state of public health is shocking: our infant mortality rate is 42.15 (deaths/1,000 live births 2013) – on par with India; Zimbabwe’s is 27.25.

Equally, we spend more than any BRICS country on public education (10.1% of GDP, 2010) and the quality of education delivered is in inverse proportion to the spend. A report published by the World Economic Forum has ranked the quality of South Africa’s maths and science education last out of 148 countries. And we boast the highest Gini coefficient in the world.

This massive misspend is funde d in large measure by our tax revenues (40% individual maximum rate). New Zealand’s is 33% and Canada’s 50%. The difference is that they spend and monitor their spend in the most efficient manner. We don’t. We do spend a fortune on consultants though: in January this year the Auditor-General implored government to immediately implement stricter financial controls to curb expenditure on consultants, which has amounted to $9 billion in three years. Only 124 contracts amounting to $2.1 billion were audited. Our GDP is $350 billion.

The Freedom Charter, the lodestar of the ANC, and our stellar constitution that enshrines dignity and human rights seem to have become words that belie our actions. Perhaps that’s why Jeff Radebe, South Africa’s longest continuously serving cabinet minister was moved to pronounce in June this year “The ANC’s vision of a non-racial, non-sexist, democratic, equal and prosperous society basically summarises the Freedom Charter.” Aren’t you relieved?

I’m not. My forebears came to this country in the 1870s and successive generations have evinced an unbroken record of service in the struggle against Apartheid and towards a better life for all –many were ANC to their very marrow. They paid with their blood; mine’s beginning to run cold.

https://www.facebook.com/photo.php fbid=10153561440836002&set=a.10152927941116002.1073741826.720016001&type=1&theater

Loading

1 December 2014 admin
← શબ્દ અને અપશબ્દ
દર્શક-જન્મશતાબ્દી સાહિત્યમિલન →

Search by

Opinion

  • રૂપ, કુરૂપ
  • કમલા હેરિસ રાજનીતિ છોડે છે, જાહેરજીવન નહીં
  • શંકા
  • ગાઝા સંહાર : વિશ્વને તાકી રહેલી નૈતિક કટોકટી
  • સ્વામી : પિતૃસત્તાક સમાજમાં ભણેલી સ્ત્રીના પ્રેમ અને લગ્નના દ્વંદ્વની કહાની

Diaspora

  • ૧લી મે કામદાર દિન નિમિત્તે બ્રિટનની મજૂર ચળવળનું એક અવિસ્મરણીય નામ – જયા દેસાઈ
  • પ્રવાસમાં શું અનુભવ્યું?
  • એક બાળકની સંવેદના કેવું પરિણામ લાવે છે તેનું આ ઉદાહરણ છે !
  • ઓમાહા શહેર અનોખું છે અને તેના લોકો પણ !
  • ‘તીર પર કૈસે રુકૂં મૈં, આજ લહરોં મેં નિમંત્રણ !’

Gandhiana

  • સ્વરાજ પછી ગાંધીજીએ ઉપવાસ કેમ કરવા પડ્યા?
  • કચ્છમાં ગાંધીનું પુનરાગમન !
  • સ્વતંત્ર ભારતના સેનાની કોકિલાબહેન વ્યાસ
  • અગ્નિકુંડ અને તેમાં ઊગેલું ગુલાબ
  • ડૉ. સંઘમિત્રા ગાડેકર ઉર્ફે ઉમાદીદી – જ્વલંત કર્મશીલ અને હેતાળ મા

Poetry

  • બણગાં ફૂંકો ..
  • ગણપતિ બોલે છે …
  • એણે લખ્યું અને મેં બોલ્યું
  • આઝાદીનું ગીત 
  • પુસ્તકની મનોવ્યથા—

Samantar Gujarat

  • ખાખરેચી સત્યાગ્રહ : 1-8
  • મુસ્લિમો કે આદિવાસીઓના અલગ ચોકા બંધ કરો : સૌને માટે એક જ UCC જરૂરી
  • ભદ્રકાળી માતા કી જય!
  • ગુજરાતી અને ગુજરાતીઓ … 
  • છીછરાપણાનો આપણને રાજરોગ વળગ્યો છે … 

English Bazaar Patrika

  • Letters by Manubhai Pancholi (‘Darshak’)
  • Vimala Thakar : My memories of her grace and glory
  • Economic Condition of Religious Minorities: Quota or Affirmative Action
  • To whom does this land belong?
  • Attempts to Undermine Gandhi’s Contribution to Freedom Movement: Musings on Gandhi’s Martyrdom Day

Profile

  • સ્વતંત્ર ભારતના સેનાની કોકિલાબહેન વ્યાસ
  • જયંત વિષ્ણુ નારળીકરઃ­ એક શ્રદ્ધાંજલિ
  • સાહિત્ય અને સંગીતનો ‘સ’ ઘૂંટાવનાર ગુરુ: પિનુભાઈ 
  • સમાજસેવા માટે સમર્પિત : કૃષ્ણવદન જોષી
  • નારાયણ દેસાઈ : ગાંધીવિચારના કર્મશીલ-કેળવણીકાર-કલમવીર-કથાકાર

Archives

“Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery that mediocrity can pay to greatness.” – Oscar Wilde

Opinion Team would be indeed flattered and happy to know that you intend to use our content including images, audio and video assets.

Please feel free to use them, but kindly give credit to the Opinion Site or the original author as mentioned on the site.

  • Disclaimer
  • Contact Us
Copyright © Opinion Magazine. All Rights Reserved